In 1974, an unusually philosophical drama set in 1930s Los Angeles found itself hailed as an instant classic, with eleven Oscar nominations at the following year’s ceremony and almost unanimously rave reviews. Had it not been for the insanely tough competition of The Godfather: Part II at the 1975 Oscars, Chinatown would have cleaned up. As it was, the only Academy Award for that near-perfect movie was for screenwriter Robert Towne.
Thirty years on, Towne has returned to the same 1930s LA of Chinatown, this time as director as well as writer, adapting a classic 1939 John Fante novel of Depression-era cross-cultural romance, long mooted for a screen outing.
Although Towne was responsible for the screenplays for a number of other 1970s hit movies, and was at the forefront of the decade’s revitalisation of Hollywood through his work on the likes of The Last Detail, Shampoo and especially Chinatown, his star has somewhat diminished in the last couple of decades after lacklustre, mediocre work on a number of bog-standard movies like Tequila Sunrise, Days of Thunder and Mission: Impossible II. His directorial career has likewise not been especially well-regarded and, in the US, his adaptation of this classic American novel has come in for a lot of criticism.
But to expect anyone to live up to the genius of Chinatown is unrealistic and, really, rather unfair. Likewise, to expect any adaptation of any novel to do full justice to the original author’s work misses the essential point that where a novel will generally be several hundred pages long and take a bare minimum of several hours to read, a film version has to cram as much as possible in to just a couple of hours. When the central theme is the blossoming of mixed-race romance in a disapproving society and the pressures of embarking on a largely sedentary literary career, some of the nuances and subtlety of the novel’s more versatile form are naturally going to be lost.
Yet for those unfamiliar with the book, as most British audiences will be, there is much to applaud here. Salma Hayek as the illiterate Mexican waitress and Colin Farrell as the aspiring Italian writer desperate for the American dream of success and a beautiful blonde wife both give believably absorbing performances, their nascent relationship given plenty of time to emerge thanks to Towne’s leisurely pacing.
But the real beauty here is not the plot or the evocation of the artistic struggle, although Towne and Farrell respectively make good stabs at them, it is instead the recreation of an era. Thanks largely to the beautiful cinematography of Caleb Deschanel, probably best known for his work on 2004’s The Passion of the Christ, combined with some superb period sets and costumes from the Coen brothers’ favourite Production Designer, Dennis Gassner, the look of this film is slick and near-perfect. When Farrell dons his trilby, he could almost be Jack Nicholson in Chinatown all over again – albeit without the bloody nose.
That kind of classic Hollywood style is rare these days, and almost worth the price of admission on its own. A visually wonderful, intelligent film with good performances from the leads, if you’re expecting another Chinatown you’ll be disappointed – but if you have those sorts of expectations you should be used to that by now.